The Democrats who hadn’t had a
President in the White House in twenty-eight years looked upon this election as
a golden opportunity to regain some self-respect. This is the year to pull it
off, they reasoned, with the Republican party displaying such a tainted
candidate. In contrast to Blaine, the Democrats nominated the reform governor
of New York, Stephen Grover Cleveland. Cleveland was a man of high integrity,
thoroughly honest and highly principled. The Democrats referred to him as
“Grover the Good”.
It was inevitable as the
presidential campaign ground its way toward the election that the Mulligan
Letters once more would make their presence felt. The Democrats made these
letters the focus of their attention when in their torchlight parades they
chanted as they marched down the busy streets of America, “James G. Blaine,
James G. Blaine, the continental liar from the state of Maine, BURN THESE
LETTERS, BURN THESE LETTERS!”
The Republicans now felt that
they had to put Cleveland under the microscope. Nobody could be that good, they
reasoned. They put their best men on the case to look into every conceivable
aspect of Cleveland’s life. EUREKA! shouted the Republicans when it was
discovered that Cleveland had earlier seduced a widow and was now the proud father
of an eight year old boy.
The Democrats, upon learning of
the Republicans’ discovery charged Cleveland to assume the role of a master
politician and lie about it. “Tell the truth” was Cleveland’s instructions to
his campaigners. He told them that he had cared for the child and had not a
thing to be ashamed of. Reverend Henry Ward Beecher inadvertently cost
Cleveland some votes with his misguided support when he stated, “If every New
Yorker who violated the seventh commandment voted for Cleveland, he would win
by a 200,000 plurality.” Nonetheless, the Republicans were now to give the
Democrats a taste of their own medicine when, in their torchlight parades, they
chanted, “Hey, Ma! Where’s my Pa!” (The Democrats were later able to answer,
“Gone to the White House, Ha! Ha! Ha!”)
As election day neared, the
Republicans were running scared. It would take a united Republican party to
defeat the Democrats they felt. They knew the chances weren’t very good, but
nevertheless they approached the Mugwumps and asked if they could see fit to
support Blaine for the presidency. Their answer was swift and resolute, “We do
not engage in criminal practice.” So much for the Mugwumps, the Republicans
reasoned.
On the very eve of the election
an incident occurred that all but sealed the fate of the Republican party. At a
dinner given in honor of Blaine one of the speakers, a Reverend Burchard,
stated that he personally would never vote for a president whose antecedents
were a party of “Rum, Romanism, and Rebellion.” It would have been real shrewd
if Blaine had paid attention to the Reverend (some say that a very tiring
campaign resulted in Blaine grabbing a few winks.) Whatever the reason, Blaine
did not clarify his position on that point. This statement was a slap in the
face to all Catholics and it so happened that New York was to become the
pivotal state in this election and New York voters were well represented by
Catholics. Blaine's wife was a Catholic and while it may appear that Blaine did
not share the conviction of Reverend Burchard, his silence made him appear
suspect in the eyes of the Catholic voter. As it turned out, Cleveland won New
York by a meager 1149 votes and with New York, the presidency. It is also
extremely important to note that the Mugwumps voted for Cleveland in this
election.
President Cleveland believed that
“a public office is a public trust.” He doubled the classified list much to the
disappointment of fellow Democrats who after twenty-eight years were eager to
cash in on the spoils of victory.
A somewhat strange situation
faced President Cleveland as he entered the White House. The government was
faced with an embarrassing surplus in the treasury. The surplus came mainly
from the high protective tariff levied on imports during the Civil War and
which was continued following the war. The surplus was an evil because the
money should have been in circulation to benefit a growing economy.
In an attempt to aid the
government shed its embarrassment over the surplus two remedies were tossed
about; the G.A.R., (an acronym for Grand Army of the Republic), came up with
hundreds of pension bills for veterans of the Civil War. These bills were
passed by Congress and sent to the President for his signature. The President,
in investigating these bills found out that many of them were for deserters
from the Union Army, some of the bills were for persons who never served in the
armed forces of the United States, and some were for veterans who became
disabled at their workplace and not from any service connected injury. Cleveland
vetoed over 200 such bills