It is nice when I find a pre 1900 Martial arts teacher or student to talk to. Usually they started out studying sporting arts and gravitated to the ancient arts. You would be surprised at the number of sporting artist who think that the art they have studied for years is hundreds of years old. Granted the father of their art are pre 1900, but the sporting arts such as karate-do were created around 1900 and developed even to this day. Judo was created from Ju-Jutsu I believe in the year 1882 by Jigoro Kano Sensei. So as you can see the sporting arts are as old as the family car. Why it is nice to talk to a pre 1900 Artist is that with sporting artist I find myself giving a history lesson which is not always welcome. Some sporting artists do not want the image of what they have been taught challenged.
If an instructor was taught that his art is what the Samurai or the Shaolin Monks practiced he tends to believe this to be true. Then along comes Ken and tells them that Samurai and Shaolin did not practice blocks and they believe their art is being attacked.
When I talk to the Pre 1900 Artist, because most have had the same experience the conversation is that of technique and history not Sport vs. Pre 1900.
Don’t think I mind explaining the differences in the arts, I don’t mind at all. I do however not wish to entice controversy.
You would be surprised at how irate students and teachers can become when they think you are attacking something that is very dear to them.
Arts at one time were all related. This is because they were in a constant development of change. Artists from China came to ports as seamen, dignitaries, and even pirates. As the Chinese art mingled with the Te in the Okinawan ports they were spread and developed. Many students with differing skills would develop their art as master teachers, and all had their view of the arts. Some grappled more then kicked and punched. Some just the opposite. Some like the hard style, some soft and flowing.
As time went on styles were the norm and not systems. Styles are a small section of the whole. Where as a system covers much more of the whole. No system covers it all. But what systems do offer is combat technique in all areas of combat.
Maybe a better way of explaining this would be to say all distances of combat. The kicking to punching of Kata, inside technique of Kata, the knees and elbows, throws, ground work, as well as submissions locks, breaks, and chokes. Some systems such as Kempo-Jitsu also teach speed fighting. The purpose of the paper above is not to promote one art over any other.
Its purpose is to explain that there is a difference between Pre 1900 Arts and Sporting Arts.
Many people love the contest of sport. The glory of being the best at a meet. The getting together with one hundred players and being crowned the best. If this is your goal the sporting arts are for you.
If you are in contest with no one but yourself yesterday, if self defense and perfection of Muscle Manipulation, Bone Dislocation, Vein and Breath Disruption, and Pressure Point Attack is your goals then Pre 1900 art is for you. There is a difference and you get to decide which path to take.